WorkplaceHero
All insights

Teacher CPD records for performance review: selecting evidence and next steps

5 min read
Jump to a section
  1. 1Confirm the purpose and period of the review
  2. 2Select learning connected to an objective
  3. 3Separate what you tried from what you know
  4. 4Choose evidence you are allowed to share
  5. 5Build a concise review summary
  6. 6Agree a next development step
  7. 7Make an evidence shortlist before writing a summary
  8. 8A fictional objective-to-evidence example
  9. 9Distinguish evidence of attendance from evidence of application
  10. 10What if the outcome is mixed or the objective changed?
  11. 11Sharing evidence without exposing confidential information
  12. 12Where an annual/appraisal review pack helps
  13. 13Finish with a development conversation, not a document dump

Preparing for performance review is a different task from keeping your day-to-day learning log. This guide assumes your records already exist and helps you select evidence, explain what it shows and identify what you want to develop next. If you need the everyday recording method, start with CPD records for teachers.

Confirm the purpose and period of the review

Read your school's review arrangements and agreed objectives. Check the dates and documents requested rather than assuming every school uses the same process. A CPD summary supports a conversation; it does not replace a required form or establish a pay progression outcome.

Select learning connected to an objective

Choose entries that help explain development relevant to the review. For each, connect the objective, the learning activity, the action you took and the evidence available. Explain gaps honestly. A long list of attendance certificates is not the same as an account of development.

Separate what you tried from what you know

Use three different statements: what you learned, what you changed and what you observed. If you have only planned an action, say so. If results were mixed or other factors may explain a change, keep that context.

A fictional example:

My objective included developing clearer feedback. Following peer discussion, I trialled a shorter written prompt. Work samples suggest some pupils responded more directly, but I have not established whether the prompt caused that change. I would like to review the approach with a colleague before extending it.

This is a discussion example, not a model that guarantees acceptance or a successful review.

Choose evidence you are allowed to share

A personal learning note, authorised observation feedback or appropriately anonymised work sample can explain different parts of the story. Follow your school's information-handling rules. Do not transfer identifiable pupil work or confidential documents into a personal tool without permission.

Build a concise review summary

Organise selected entries under the relevant objectives. For each objective, describe the learning, action, available evidence and next question. Keep access to the fuller record where it is needed, but share only what the recipient is authorised to see.

Agree a next development step

Bring questions about support, time, observation or further learning. Record the agreed next step and how it will be revisited. Use annual CPD planning to connect the review with future learning, rather than treating the meeting as the end of the process.

Make an evidence shortlist before writing a summary

Start with the agreed objectives and the relevant review period. For each objective, choose records that explain a development need, the learning undertaken and what followed. The following prompts organise your preparation; they do not replace your school's required documents.

  • Objective or question: what was the development intended to support?
  • Selected learning: which entry is relevant, and why?
  • Action: what did you actually try or change?
  • Evidence: what can you appropriately show or discuss?
  • Limitations: what is uncertain or not yet evaluated?
  • Next step: what support or further learning would help?

An entry outside the period may provide background, but should not be presented as current-period learning. A planned course is a future action, not evidence of completed development.

A fictional objective-to-evidence example

Imagine an agreed development objective about making task explanations clearer. The teacher selects an INSET note, an authorised peer discussion and a later reflection on a small trial. They do not submit every certificate from the year just because it is available.

The learning note explains why they separated the first instruction from later checks. The follow-up says what they observed, while acknowledging that classes and tasks differed. A concise summary might read:

I explored clearer task instructions through INSET and peer discussion. I trialled a shorter opening instruction and reflected on the responses. My notes suggest it may be worth continuing, but I have not established a consistent effect. I would value a further observation and discussion before extending the approach.

This gives the reviewer something to discuss: the reasoning, the evidence and the proposed support. It is not a promise that the objective is achieved or that a particular review outcome should follow.

Distinguish evidence of attendance from evidence of application

A certificate can support that a course was completed. A learning note explains your interpretation. Authorised observation feedback may illuminate an application. A later reflection can record what you noticed and the questions still open. None of those documents automatically answers every question on its own.

For example, attaching a feedback-course certificate does not demonstrate improved feedback practice. Explain what you took from it and whether you tried anything. Where you have no application evidence yet, say so and propose a next step rather than stretching the claim.

What if the outcome is mixed or the objective changed?

A change in class, role, timetable or available support may affect how the development unfolded. State the context and distinguish what you undertook from what you were unable to evaluate. Do not rewrite the original objective as if a later change had always been agreed.

Bring relevant questions to the meeting: is the objective still appropriate, what support is needed and how should the next action be revisited? Follow the school's review arrangements for documenting any agreed changes. A personal CPD note is not an authorisation to amend a formal objective unilaterally.

Sharing evidence without exposing confidential information

Check who will receive the summary, what they need and which systems the school requires. Do not place identifiable pupil work, safeguarding details or confidential colleague feedback in a personal export. Anonymisation needs care: removing a name may not remove identifying context.

Where evidence must remain within the school system, refer to it through the authorised process rather than copying it into a personal tool. Ask the relevant school contact if you are unsure. Keep the summary focused on professional learning, not private details about other people.

Where an annual/appraisal review pack helps

PassportPro's annual/appraisal review pack can help organise selected learning records for the period you choose. Review the selected highlights and decide whether to include reflections. Check the dates, wording and attachments before sharing anything.

The pack is an administrative aid, not a school's official review form, proof of objective completion or a pay progression decision. It cannot determine the appropriateness of confidential evidence for you. Free Passport remains available for manual records and standards linking.

Finish with a development conversation, not a document dump

Prepare a few focused questions: which approach should I investigate further, what observation or coaching would help and when can we discuss what happened? Agree a feasible next step within the school's arrangements and retain the permitted summary of that agreement.

For England-specific context, consult the Teachers' standards and standard for teachers' professional development. Schools and jurisdictions differ; these sources should not be treated as a universal UK review procedure.

Start your free Passport to maintain your personal records. For ongoing recording during term, return to the everyday teacher CPD guide.

Frequently asked questions

Which CPD entries should I bring to a teacher performance review?

Choose entries relevant to your agreed objectives and the review period. Explain learning, action, evidence and any uncertainty, following your school's review arrangements.

What if I have not seen an outcome from the learning yet?

Describe what you learned and what you intend to try. Do not present a planned action as an observed result.

Read this next

Or skip the reading and start your free Passport - free for life for individuals.

Your professional learning record

Keep your own learning and reflections in Passport, and check your body's current requirements separately.

Save your learning to Passport

Sign in to save what you've read - we'll create a free CPD log for you.